Bühler MWPF-E Single-Spout Packer (Compaction) VS Haver & Boecker ELEMENTAR Single-Spout Packer
Detailed side-by-side comparison of specifications, pricing, features, and suitability.
| Specification | Bühler MWPF-E Single-Spout Packer (Compaction) | Haver & Boecker ELEMENTAR Single-Spout Packer |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Packer | Packer |
| Material | Multi | Multi |
| Automation | Full Auto | Full Auto |
| Speed (bags/hr) | 420–1200 | 300–600 |
| Layers | — | — |
| Bag Width (mm) | 250–550 | — |
| Bag Length (mm) | 350–900 | — |
| Price (USD) | $65,000–$160,000 | $60,000–$120,000 |
| Power (kW) | 11 kW | 8 kW |
| Weight (tons) | 3.2 t | 2 t |
| Print Colors | N/A | N/A |
Comparison Summary
In our side-by-side comparison, the Haver & Boecker ELEMENTAR Single-Spout Packer leads in 2 out of 3 measurable categories. However, the best choice depends on your specific production requirements, budget, and regional availability.
Bühler MWPF-E Single-Spout Packer (Compaction)
Bühler MWPF-E single-spout packer with shaker compaction. 7-20 bags/min. For flour and fine powders requiring compaction.
Advantages
- Shaker compaction
- Flour specialist
- 7-20 bags/min
- Swiss engineering
Considerations
- Single spout
Haver & Boecker ELEMENTAR Single-Spout Packer
Haver & Boecker ELEMENTAR single-spout packer. 300-600 bags/hr for valve bags. Electronic weighing, compact design. Entry-level Haver quality for smaller cement plants.
Advantages
- Haver quality entry level
- 300-600 bags/hr
- Compact design
- Electronic weighing
Considerations
- Single spout only
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is faster, Bühler MWPF-E Single-Spout Packer (Compaction) or Haver & Boecker ELEMENTAR Single-Spout Packer?
The Bühler MWPF-E Single-Spout Packer (Compaction) has a higher maximum speed of 1200 bags/hr compared to 600 bags/hr.
Which is more affordable, Bühler MWPF-E Single-Spout Packer (Compaction) or Haver & Boecker ELEMENTAR Single-Spout Packer?
The Haver & Boecker ELEMENTAR Single-Spout Packer starts at a lower price point ($60,000). However, total cost of ownership includes maintenance, power, and spare parts.
Can I use Bühler MWPF-E Single-Spout Packer (Compaction) and Haver & Boecker ELEMENTAR Single-Spout Packer for cement bag production?
Both machines can be evaluated for cement bag applications. Check the material compatibility, bag dimensions, and automation level against your specific production requirements.