Botheven VS-20 Valve Forming Line VS Yideng Complete Cement Bag Line (YD-5860+2018)
Detailed side-by-side comparison of specifications, pricing, features, and suitability.
| Specification | Botheven VS-20 Valve Forming Line | Yideng Complete Cement Bag Line (YD-5860+2018) |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Complete Line | Complete Line |
| Material | Pp Woven | Paper |
| Automation | Full Auto | Full Auto |
| Speed (bags/hr) | 17–25 | 120–200 |
| Layers | 1–1 | 2–5 |
| Bag Width (mm) | 500–650 | 300–600 |
| Bag Length (mm) | 670–1200 | 350–1300 |
| Price (USD) | $80,000–$150,000 | $140,000–$300,000 |
| Power (kW) | 20 kW | 80 kW |
| Weight (tons) | 4 t | 14 t |
| Print Colors | N/A | 4-color |
Comparison Summary
In our side-by-side comparison, the Yideng Complete Cement Bag Line (YD-5860+2018) leads in 4 out of 7 measurable categories. However, the best choice depends on your specific production requirements, budget, and regional availability.
Botheven VS-20 Valve Forming Line
Botheven VS-20 valve forming line. Hot air sealing for coated PP woven block bottom valve bags. Also BOPP/WPP block bottom types. 17-25 bags/min. Cement and fertilizer rated.
Advantages
- Hot air valve sealing
- Block bottom quality
- Cement/fertilizer rated
- 35+ years Taiwanese quality
Considerations
- 17-25 bags/min max
- Valve forming only
Yideng Complete Cement Bag Line (YD-5860+2018)
Yideng complete cement bag line: YD-5860 tuber (450/min) + YD-2018-18 bottomer (200/min). 2-5 layers, building materials rated, matched production speeds.
Advantages
- Complete Yideng matched line
- 450/200 min speeds
- 5-layer capability
Considerations
- Chinese equipment
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is faster, Botheven VS-20 Valve Forming Line or Yideng Complete Cement Bag Line (YD-5860+2018)?
The Yideng Complete Cement Bag Line (YD-5860+2018) has a higher maximum speed of 200 bags/hr compared to 25 bags/hr.
Which is more affordable, Botheven VS-20 Valve Forming Line or Yideng Complete Cement Bag Line (YD-5860+2018)?
The Botheven VS-20 Valve Forming Line starts at a lower price point ($80,000). However, total cost of ownership includes maintenance, power, and spare parts.
Can I use Botheven VS-20 Valve Forming Line and Yideng Complete Cement Bag Line (YD-5860+2018) for cement bag production?
Both machines can be evaluated for cement bag applications. Check the material compatibility, bag dimensions, and automation level against your specific production requirements.